Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts

Monday, March 16, 2009

The 'History' of Caligula: An essay for class

The 'History' of Caligula

Robert M. Barga

For a full version of my Movie Review please go here:

http://whalertly.blogspot.com/2009/03/blu-ray-review-caligula-1979.html

or: http://blogcritics.org/archives/2009/03/12/101729.php




Caligula is one of the most mature, and most pornographic, 'main stream' movies ever to be released. The movie, which was released in 1979, contains the acting of some of the best actors of the era, interjected with the hard core sex of some of the worst actors of the era. Controversy has surrounded the film since it showed up, usually regarding the mature nature of the film, the blatant interjection of porn, and the blind side that the producers pulled on the actor. Usually ignored in this controversy is the fact that the history of Caligula is not exactly what is desired from a retelling of hisotry. Caligula and real history really do not seem to go together.


Caligula tells the story of a fledging Roman youth (I wonder what his name is) as he migrates from being the heir to the throne to being the emperor to being beheaded. This movie starts with Caligula’s rise to power, when he is frolicking in the woods having sex with his sister. It then moves on to when he ascertains the throne of Rome and discusses his popularity and love. Finally, the movie comes crashing down due to the madness that is associated more often with Nero. The movie does this in a somewhat slow paced fashion, which surprisingly fits the film. Oh, and on a side note, it interjects hard-core pornography throughout.

Moving on from the discussion of the plot of the movie, it becomes apparent that the history in Caligula is lacking. Ancient Rome was not sexually obsessed in any manner. As a Roman History major put it, “They were much more open about sex; however, they were also far more conservative then modern America.1” Basically, the Romans were fine with the concept of sex, but they were not having sex all of the time, nor were they having sex in public. This is a major theme of Caligula, and one that is greatly incorrect. No matter what somebody might see saying otherwise, the Romans were not hyper sexualized.

The rise to power by Caligula was not one of deceit and killing, as it was depicted in the movie. Instead, Caligula's family was killed by his adopted uncle, and then he waited until that uncle died naturally to become emperor; in the movie Caligula kills his uncle and his sister (with whom he has sexual relations) is still alive. After this, for the next two years, Caligula led a decent, moral, and much enjoyed reign2.

According to Caligula, he not only killed his uncle, but he immediately led a perverse and violent regime, one not enjoyed by the people. This is a great falsehood, but it is one that is acceptable for the movie. As his actual reign moved into a immoral and horrific one, it made sense for the movie to start with this setting, so that it can move quickly into the actual meat of the movie. That is, the movie is designed to be inaccurate here because the otherwise needed character interplay and growth would be too large.

The rest of Caligula's reign, after those initial two years, was marked with gruesome and perverse interests. This seemed to occur immediately after his illness3. As his mind changed, Caligula started to kill off random people, including many family friends. He also decided to randomly invade Britain, much to the hatred of his generals4. Caligula focused mainly on this nature of the emperor, and it was done quite well. Though it was far too focused on his sexual perversions, the actual nature of his other attacks, specifically the move on Britain, were well covered by the movie. This made sense, as the actual nature of the movie was to examine the perversions and immoral aspect of Caligula.

Caligula seems to divulge from the real nature of Caligula's history because it needs to target a specific audience. People who enjoy pornography, or anything of this nature, seem to want to look at immoral and more violent fare. A movie which focuses, for the most part, on the immoral nature of Caligula fits far better into this demographic. Toss in incest (which never happened), gay sex (when in Rome...), and a ton of violence and you have a nice mix for this audience.

It seems as though Caligula was designed to focus far more on the later nature of Caligula's reign, once he had gone crazy and off the rocker. Additionally, it added several untrue features to further the overall enjoyment of the target audience. Most movies seem to do this, and Caligula is in no way alone with this. Caligula has a few parts of history correct, most specifically when talking about invading Britain, but it generally failed its exam. Overall, it seems as though Caligula missed the mark if it was aiming at history – as do most movies based on history (see 3005) – but hit the mark if it was aiming at its target demographic.

1IM conversation with Lucas Proctor, copy can be provided

2“On the Embassy to Gaius”, Volume Two – Philo of Alexandria

3“On the Embassy to Gaius”, Volume Two – Philo of Alexandria

4“Natural History” Volume Eleven - Pliny the Elder

Read more ...

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

The Variable Americans

Hey all, this is my history midterm for Hist. 152. The main prompt was, more or less, asking what changes there were to American citizenship after reconstruction until WW1. I analyzed the information, and came up with what I believe is a correct paper. I classified people by their race, their gender, and various other linking factors. Please do not consider that to be racist in nature, merely my best way to actually argue my points.
Please feel free to comment on it or use it as you see fit. Also, feel free to argue with it.
Enjoy

(ps, if you want my sources please let me know)



What does it mean to be American? This question, and those derived from it, has been argued over throughout American History. From the blocking of black voting rights, to the arresting union leaders, to the taking out of the commies, the definition of an American has been large-scale, long-term, evolution to what it is now. The blacks got a say, then promptly lost it. The women slowly gained the vote, state by state, region by region. The Chinese and the Irish had to fight to get any say what-so-ever. Union workers were killed and arrested, simply because they dared to question what it was to be American, what the American dream was, and were different. Throughout American history, people of various groups and races attempted to gain the same rights as other Americans; these people were struck down at each and every turn by other American citizens, including those who had just fought for their rights. The question, quite simply, becomes: what were these groups that tried to rise up, and how did fellow Americans fight back?


For almost a century, America had gone without having any person besides white men having a voice. Sure, there were the occasional woman who owned land, thus letting them vote, but the vast majority of women, and absolutely all blacks, were banned from politics in its entirety. America seemed to function decently well as a republic that had only a small portion of its people voting, and it seemed to be destined to remain on that course. The Civil War, in its existence and aftermath, abruptly changed this progression. Suddenly, blacks were humans – no longer a mere 3/5ths of onei – and they were given the right to vote. Congress acted swiftly, and with great force, passing various Amendments to the Constitution and making it so that this right was protectedii. It seemed as though blacks were to be given full rights of the laws.


For most of the country, this was an abrupt and unwelcome change. Most Americans considered the blacks to be below themselves, and thus they were outraged at their allowance into the voting ranks. There were riots, protests, and hundreds of lynchingsiii. Groups sprung up in the southiv to 'protect' the American ideals and to make sure that blacks knew their place. America was torn over the issue, with the north supporting it, the south opposing it, and the west just looking for cheap labor, no matter what the source. This overall struggle amongst the American people led to other social issues being brought up, and it caused several other larger problems.


The compromise of 1877v, which was enacted as Hayes took the executive office, just as quickly stripped rights away from blacks. Sure, they Constitutionally had the rights, but there was to be no enforcement of it. Jim Crow laws, named after a popular comicvi, appeared out of thin air to keep the blacks down. Grandfather clauses, literacy tests, and poll taxes were a legal means to grant the vote to whites only. The KKK, along with various other hate groups, formed to make sure that no blacks would dare challenge this issue, and to punish them if they tried. Blacks were scared into submission, and, again, deemed as second class citizens.


After blacks gained their voice, and then promptly lost it, their was a new challenge to the white male citizenship, that of the Chinese. Coming from their homeland in search of a job, and usually working on the railroadsvii, the Chinese were a force to be dealt with. This large block of people had a common bond, a common nationality, and a common goal. While they were not fighting for the right to vote, they were arguing that they deserved citizenship. They came here to unite the country rail-by-rail, and they wanted to make sure that they were justly rewarded. The Supreme Court, in various rulings, quickly gave them their citizenshipviii.


This change irked Americans more then the black issue had; blacks, at least, were natives of this country, the Chinese were not. Americans across the country were united against allowing Chinese citizenship, and they did not believe that it would be a good idea. In the north and south, where they were dealing with their own labor and foreign issues, they were more neutral to the idea. But in the mid-west, where the Chinese were working, and the west, where they were living, the people were greatly opposed to granting them citizenship. Why should people from another country, especially those who looked vastly different then us, be allowed to vote and get the benefits that are inherent in being American?


On the east coast, the populace was fighting with their own immigration problems. An influx of persons, most coming through Ellis Island, was making the entire seacoast a multi-cultural pot of stew. Irish, Italians, and Germans were all coming over for work. Once they came over, they quickly formed their own communities. With their own neighborhoods, their own restaurants, and there own newspapers, the immigrants were quickly isolating themselves from main-stream Americansix. While they were initially inclined to avoid our government and politics, these immigrants were quickly swept up in the political machine and were essential cogs for the Tammany Hall crowdx. This caused them to immediately get into the American political system as soon as they stepped off of the boat.


The American people did not like the new immigrants. Signs banning Irish from applying for jobs sprang up all around the country.xi The new people, usually speaking their own language and doing their home-country customs, scared the American populace. Plus, both the Irish and the Italians were Catholics, which directly attacked the protestant majority in the country. Americans, in general, did not like these changes. While the politicians were using the immigrants for their own gains, the majority of Americans were trying to kick them out. Groups that wanted temperance were fighting the immigrant simply because they perceived that alcohol was inherent in these persons. Just as it was with the Chinese in the west, the Immigrants in the east were dealing with social stigma and were rejected.


While most groups that wanted to be added into the American citizenry were easy to identify, either by a common language, a common race, or a common culture, there was one group that was made up by anybody and everybody: the unions. In the early 1900s, there were issues with the way that labor worked in America. The people wanted higher wages, a safer environment, and bosses who actually gave a damn. The unions realized that the only way to get what they wanted would be to form into groups and protest. These protests slowed down commerce, harmed the countries economy, and made most people hate the unions. While this caused a lot of backlash and hatred towards the unions, it was hard to tell who was a union member, or “red neckxii”, and who wasn't, as they shared no common bond.


Americans generally hate it when anybody effects their pocketbooks. They hate it when there is a group that harms the economy. They hate it when anything causes them extra stress. The unions did all of these, and so Americans really did not support themxiii. For obvious reasons, the capitalistic aspect of society also disliked the unions. Most Americans related unions to either the Irish or the Communists, often both. Using this dislike, many politicians started to charge communists and unionists with crimes. Anti-union police forces took down hundreds of strikes, and injured/killed hundredsxiv. This vast backlash showed that not only were unions not considered citizens, but that the Commies were not either.


America, throughout her history, has been filled with one group trying to gain rights and citizenship. When they attempted to rise in the social hierarchy, most of their fellow Americans would push them back down. This cycle was continuous, from the blacks, to the women, to all immigrants, to the unions, and then to the blacks again; America would not accept civil rights and citizenship unless there was a hard fight for them. This has caused many groups to back down, many groups to give up, and many groups to never get their rights. Until the start of WW1, most groups in America had little rights, and most Americans thought that only the WASPs should be citizens. While it did not change immediately, the years after WW1 slowly brought the change that was needed to the country, slowly the populace started to accept others. This process towards civil rights, and equal rights, was a long-term struggle, and one that is going on today. Any group that wishes to have their rights needs to remember this one thing from American history: you might get those rights, but it is going to be a long, tedious, and damn-hard fight to get them.

Read more ...

Friday, January 30, 2009

The Burning of the Flag

The Burning of the Flag


Robert M. Barga


Should the United States of America annex the Philippines? Should the country that strove to leave on empire attempt to create another? Does America owe it to the savages of the world to govern them with a just system? These questions plagued Americans at the turn of the 20th century and greatly influenced all future policies of the National Government. After winning the Spanish-American War, America was faced with a large problem: what to do with the island nation of the Philippines? Americans on both sides of the issue, Imperialists who supported annexation and Anti-Imperialists who supported Philippine freedom, often clashed on the issue. Emerging from this din on the imperialist side was Albert Beveridge, a Republican politician from Indiana. Humanity and religion, The American Way, and the economy, argued Beveridge, all pointed towards the annexation of the Philippines1.

Beveridge's main argument for the annexation of the Philippines revolved around his views of humanity and of religion. He believed that Americans, along with the western Europeans, were granted permission by The Almighty God to be the spreaders of liberty and freedom. By constantly referring God and what He has granted to the United States - “He has marked us as His chosen people”2 - , Beveridge was arguing that it was the solemn duty of America to colonize and work to 'free' the people of the Philippines. He was arguing that it was the God-granted duty to do this. However, to avoid merely focusing on God, he also contended that it was the humane thing to do; that to be fair to the Philippians, America must do her best to keep Germany, Japan, Russia, etc. from taking away their freedoms.

While Beveridge was able to persuade many on religious and humanistic grounds, several other thinkers contended that it was actually inhumane to annex the Philippines. William Graham Sumner, a Yale professor, was strongly opposed to the idea of annexing the Philippines3. He believed that it was fundamentally inhumane to force any class or group of citizens to change their way, merely because another group perceived them to be wrong or savage. He argued that it was inherent upon every group to be able to survive in their own way, seeking out “Their own salvation or go without”4. Furthermore, Sumner contended that the Philippians hated the American system, that they did not understand western religion, and that they were hostile to American ideas5. Overall, Sumner was contending that it is not just, not humane, and definitely not Christian to force change upon a group that clearly does not want it.

Both Beveridge and Sumner were focusing on the religious and fair-treatment demographics of America; those who thought solely with God in their minds and those that were caring about the harms caused upon other persons. This is a common appeal in America, as it is quite easy to grab a large portion of the American populace merely by appealing to one of these two issues. Beveridge had a strong argument that God had endowed Americans with the right to colonize and spread. This argument hinged on the perception of Manifest Destiny which was a strong vein, at that time, running through America. Sumner, on the other hand, hit the nail on the head when he talked about the inhumanity of colonizing the Philippians.

Beveridge then moved on to argue that the Economy of the American people depended on the colonization and the annexation of the Philippines. When he wrote “We do not need more money – we need more circulation, more employment. Therefore we must find new markets...”6, Beveridge was arguing that the economy of America needed the new markets. No government or country can survive without trade and internal spending (GDP) and all economies will grow stagnant without a large GDP. Beveridge was arguing that by annexing the Philippines the United States would be expanding its monetary base and spending allowance, thus granting it a higher GDP and a better economy.

This argument appealed greatly to the American populace. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, as with today, America had a problem with her economy. Coming off of the Panic of 18937, the American population was scared of a bad economy and the loss of money. By arguing towards their pocketbooks, Beveridge was able to convince many Americans that it was a good thing to expand into the Philippines.

The third, and primary, argument that both the Imperialists and the Anti-Imperialists used in their argument over the Philippines was that of The American Way. Beveridge argued that the “march of the flag8” was the essential reason for expanding. This was a basic appeal to patriotism, and it has been echoed throughout American Foreign Policy as a ‘rally around the flag’ effect9; this effect causes all Americans to identify as one identity, and thus to come together. Elihu Root, Secretary of War (now Defense) under McKinley argued that “[the] people inhabiting the Philippine Archipelago are incapable of self-government...10” and held that the United States had the duty to govern them properly. Using the examples of prisoners and Indians, both Roots and Beveridge argued that the American Way of government “...applies only to those who are capable...11”. Thus, it was the American Way to then govern the Philippians under those principles as they could not govern themselves.

The Anti-Imperialists, of course, countered this argument exceptionally well. Carl Schurz, a journalist and member of the Anti-Imperialist League, argued that “we maintain that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed12”. By saying this, Schurz was arguing that the Hobbsian and Lockovian view of government was the only just way, and the true American Way. He was contending that unless the local people support it, it can not be truly just and proper. Using a much more US-centric approach, Sumner contended that the American policing of the Philippians would amount to not granting them the same Constitutional rights as all other Americans. When he said “If you take away the Constitution, what is American Liberty and all the rest? Nothing but a lot of phrases...13”, Sumner was clearly arguing that the only way to preserve American freedoms and ideals would be to let the Philippines to do as they themselves wished to do. That is, grant them sovereignty and self-government.

In arguing towards the American Way, both the Imperialists and the Anti-Imperialists were targeting a mainstream demographic of the American populace. Most Americans pride themselves in being patriotic and pride themselves in their country. They all think that their country is the best in the world, and they all want to keep it that way. By appealing to this patriotism, both sides were able to grab new followers. The Imperialists were able to argue that the Founding Fathers, via their slavery and Indian relations, supported the idea of US-centric government over a lesser and more savage people. The Anti-Imperialists argued back that it was against the very foundations and ideas that America was born with. Both sides used this style of argument extensively and focused most effort on it.

Both the Imperialists and the Anti-Imperialists argued extensively over the issues of annexing the Philippines or not. Both appealed to the American Way and to the religious nature that is inherent in Americans. Both sides used intellectual arguments to make their respective cases. This system of argument, though it wound up in favor of the Imperialists, would become the main argument of intellectual conversation in America. Additionally, the conversations presented had a large impact on how America viewed the world and how the world viewed America. Becoming an empire, per say, created the American super power, which we remain today.

1 Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “The Library of Oratory, Ancient and Modern”, page 93

2Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “The Library of Oratory, Ancient and Modern”, page 93

3Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “War and Other Essays”, page 95

4Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “War and Other Essays”, page 97

5Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “War and Other Essays”, page 96

6Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “The Library of Oratory, Ancient and Modern”, page 95

8Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “The Library of Oratory, Ancient and Modern”, page 95

99 James Nachtwey: “Public Opinion and Mass Communications” page 201

10Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “The Military and Colonial Policy of the United States”, page 109

11Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “The Library of Oratory, Ancient and Modern”, page 94

12Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “Speeches, Correspondence, and Political Papers of Carl Schurz”, page 104

13Retrieving the American Past; Excerpt from “War and Other Essays”, page 96



Read more ...

Monday, January 12, 2009

The Rise of American Big-Buisnesses

While this might be a paper for history, I think that it is highly relevant to today's society. Carnegie, when he created the vertical structure of businesses (along with Rockefeller), created the system that is essential in modern day companies and governments. Without the integration that he proposed, no large-businesses would have been possible. In fact, with no multi-million dollar enterprise existing before Standard oil, the setup proposed by Carnegie and perfected by Rockefeller is factually known as the primary cause of American business growth.


Furthermore, think of this as a response to those who believe that these men, the Carnegie's, the Rockefeller's, the J.P. Morgan's, and the Chase's (as a side note, I think that it is funny that Chase talked his boss (Carnegie) into selling out to Rockefeller on a golf course) are robber barrens. Sure, they were rich. And, sure, they bought out their competition. But they created the country, and they did their best to make sure that it grew. These men made the country, and they employed thousands. Think of this paper as a defense to their impact on America.




RTAP Paper #1: On Carnegie Steel

Robert M. Barga


Steel is an expensive, difficult, and time-consuming product to make. To manufacture just one ton of steel, Carnegie Steel needed one and a half tons of iron, one and a half tons of coke, and one ton of limestone1. The process of getting just one ton of steel required four tons of other materials, the transportation and refining of the same, and the man hours. Yet, somehow, this was able to be sold for two cents per three pounds. Owning all of the necessary materials (vertical structure), as argued by Carnegie, would become essential for big businesses around America.


Carnegie's main argument is that the only cost effective, for both the consumer and the producer, means of manufacturing steel is to own all the processes that are used. If one needs to pay attention to the middle man, then one is paying cost plus profit for each item; by doing ones own processing of all parts, one is only paying the cost. Carnegie is basically contending that the cheapest product is that which is produced by the company who will use it themselves.


Taking it a step further, Carnegie contended that the only possible large-scale business is one that fits his vertical integration model. To be a business you need to be able to output at the needed rate. To output at the needed rate, you needed a constant supply. Unless the company owned the supply, the company could not keep it constant. Basically, Carnegie was also contending, along with his cost arguments, that a company needed to own all of its components if it expected to become large and wealthy.


While these contentions had their objectors (usually companies that were either put out of business or had to drastically cut costs), the overall argument appealed to the American populace, be it in theory, or be it in their pockets. By showing the country, and the World, that a product produced by a company owning all of its components (be it an oil company owning the railroads, wells, and the lumber, for barrels or a steel company owning the boats, the trains, and the mining locations) is cheaper, and more reliable, Carnegie Steel was able to show the usefulness of vertical integration. The appeal to the pocketbooks, and to the schedules, made Carnegie's contentions prevalent and well received by the American populace.


Carnegie's argument was not only persuasive to the American populace, but it was also persuasive to other businesses, both past and present. Most large-scale producing companies now own their own materials, they own everything that is needed to make their product. From Ford owning rubber plantations and iron mills, to Dole owning fruit plantations and tin mines, to US Steel (formally Carnegie Steel) still owning all of its needed components, the vertical integration model proposed by Carnegie is essential in today's modern companies. By arguing that a company should keep all of its costs down, its resources at hand, and all under central control, Carnegie was able to show exactly why a company should own, or at least have stock in, everything that it needs. This argument, as well as its accompanying model, is essential as the wellbeing and foundation of all big-businesses, both now and then.

1Retrieving The American Past; Excerpt from Carnegie's Autobiography, page 29.

Read more ...

Monday, November 10, 2008

Little Known Facts About America

On a lighter side...
Now that the election is over, and we can once again busy ourselves with our meaningless lives, I have decided to post some little known but interesting facts about America. Enjoy these, add some of your own (COMMENT PEOPLE, PLEASE, 50+ of you read this per day, somebody comment... /begging). Use these for trivial pursuit, buzztime at Bdubs, or for your showing on Jeopardy!

Enjoy

-The 'rule of thumb' is in no way regarding any law or social standard about beating a wife with a stick less than the size of ones thumb. STOP THIS RUMOR ALREADY. It is about carpentry, measurements, and inches.

-That 30 unknown facts video is full of bullshit and misleading information. I will eventually address the tax issues at some point (and the fact that they are all legal). Feel free to counter me on this

-Did you know that before leading our fledgling government, John Adams defended the British soldiers who fired (in their own defense) during the Boston Tea Party... Funny thing about this, this went into his main theory about defense in court for everybody (because the innocent until proven guilty)

-It costs only $6,400 to raise a middle age dog to 11 years old... Hmmm, maybe they are worth more than kids are

-The Main Library at Indiana University sinks over an inch every year because when it was built, engineers failed to take into account the weight of all the books that would occupy the building.

-The Eisenhower interstate system requires that one mile in every five must be straight. These straight sections are usable as airstrips in times of war or other emergencies.

-Andrew Jackson beat a man who tried to shoot him with his cane. Seriously, this was the first bad-ass (take that Chuck).

-John Hanson was the first president of America. He was black, and served back when we had ACPU.

-FDR and his lovely wife, Elanor, were second cousins.

-John Taylor became a sworn enemy of the US, shortly after he joined the Confederacy 20 after his terms ended.

-Washington is the only serving-president to lead the army, this was during the Whiskey Rebellion.

-Lincoln planned on getting rid of the blacks from this country, he believed that they could never live together.

-Lincoln only freed the slaves in the southern states, it was a political move.

-Over 10,000 soldiers fighting in the Civil War were under 18. So that they would not lie (a sin), they would put a paper with the number '18' on it in their shoe. Then, they could say that they were 'over 18' without lying.

-The first person killed by Brown at Harper's Ferry was a free black man... Go figure

-Stonewall Jackson would have made a great parent, he refused to eat foods that tasted good, as he figured them to thus be unhealthy.

-The Department of Defense used to be The Department of War. We hate sounding imperialistic and aggressive.

-Oliver Pollock, the biggest investor in the fledgling US government, created the '$' sign.

-Honest Abe is the only US president so far to hold a patent (I am biding my time).

-Jackson refused to listen to a Supreme Court Order.

-Virginia has the most presidents of any state, 8

-Ohio is a close second, with 7 (but ours like dying in office). We will tie Virginia in 30 years, when Robert M. Barga becomes president...

Feel free to add your own in here, pass this around, or do what ever you want. Read more ...

Redirect

You will be redirected shortly to our new website. If you are not redirected within 5 seconds please CLICK HERE!

Copyright Notice

(C) All articles, postings, images, etc. on this site are protected by relevant copyright law, unless otherwise specified. To use any original material in totality please ask for author permission.

(C) 2009, all rights reserved by whalertly.blogspot.com, Robert M. Barga, and all contributing authors.